CHURCHGAZETTE

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Vatican

Vatican envoy says more than 250 people from Peru's dissolved Sodalicio must be held accountable

Jordi Bertomeu, the Vatican official handling the case, says the accountability process is not finished and the full extent of abuse in the Peruvian community may not yet be known

Image accompanying a report on the Vatican investigation into abuse in the Sodalicio de Vida Cristiana in Peru
Image accompanying a report on the Vatican investigation into abuse in the Sodalicio de Vida Cristiana in Peru

Jordi Bertomeu, a canon lawyer at the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith and the pope's personal envoy for special missions, reviewed the Sodalicio de Vida Cristiana case in an interview with the Spanish Catholic website alfayomega.es. The Sodalicio is a Peruvian community that Pope Francis dissolved shortly before his death. Bertomeu, the Vatican official in charge of the case, said more than 250 people with responsibility in the organization must be held to account, and that this process is not yet complete. He also said the full scope of the abuse may not yet have come to light.

Bertomeu said it was important for listening to victims' testimony to lead to concrete decisions. Otherwise, he said, it risks becoming one more disappointment. In his view, building a Church where no one ever again suffers what the victims went through is one of the best ways to prepare for the future. He also said humanity will need safe spaces where love, fraternity, authentic relationships and responsibility can be lived, and that the Church should be one of them.

The pope's meeting with survivors in Peru

Bertomeu described Pope Leo XIV's meeting with abuse survivors during his trip to Peru as a moment of great consolation and also of hope. He said that before the trip to South America he offered guidance on organizing the meeting and suggested some names. The final decision, he said, rested with other Vatican offices, which weighed factors he does not fully know.

He acknowledged that people who are not invited often feel left out. The meeting, he said, should not be read as singling out some victims as more important than others. It should be an open door, he said, not a new dividing line between those who have been heard and those still waiting.

Knowing Leo XIV as a bishop

Bertomeu said his trust in Pope Leo XIV rests on personal dealings with him. He has known him since his time as bishop of Chiclayo, in northern Peru, when the future pope chaired the prevention commission of the Peruvian Bishops' Conference. Bertomeu said he saw the then-bishop come under media pressure precisely because of his commitment to justice in the Sodalicio case. Since 2018, according to Bertomeu, the pope has stood by the victims and by the investigative journalists who exposed what happened. Leo XIV served as a bishop in Peru until early 2023 and fought against the community. Bertomeu said he now feels the pope's closeness and support in the task he has been given.

The brutality of controlling conscience

A canonical investigation into the Sodalicio had uncovered serious abuses of power and sexual violence. But Bertomeu said what struck him most, as he heard testimony after the organization was dissolved, was the brutality of what can happen in such a setting. He was speaking of a structure that shelters behind a religious charism and uses sect-like methods to control its members' conscience and will. The most painful thing, he said, is seeing how far such manipulation can go when a person is subjected to a structure that controls every aspect of his or her life.

The Sodalicio's ideological roots

Bertomeu traced the problem to its historical setting. The Sodalicio was founded at the height of the Cold War, when South America's well-off classes feared communism would take hold in their countries and felt betrayed by the Church after the Second Vatican Council. In that climate, Bertomeu said, Luis Fernando Figari, a young Peruvian with a classist, far-right outlook, set out to found a Catholic group aimed at gaining extraordinary political and social influence.

In answer to liberation theology, Figari proposed a theology of reconciliation. In place of a Church that had made a preferential option for the poor, he offered a model of consecration to God aimed at young white people from the upper-middle and upper classes. They were called to be a kind of "half monks, half soldiers": the new leaders of Latin American Catholicism. Many saw in this an answer to their religious, social and political concerns.

Bertomeu said this is one of the core problems: institutional prestige and an appearance of orthodoxy can lead people to stop critically questioning what happens inside an organization.

Unfinished accountability and conversion in the Church

Now that the Sodalicio has been dissolved, Bertomeu said, more than 250 people involved still have to be held to account so that victims receive adequate reparation. He also said Peruvian society as a whole and the Church need help to accept their share of moral responsibility, at least by omission, and to ask forgiveness with sincere repentance.

A genuine culture of prevention, he said, requires changing mindsets, structures and behavior. Having protocols is not enough, he said, if they are not applied, if no one checks whether they work and if there is no willingness to admit mistakes.

The wider debate on child protection

The Sodalicio case comes amid a wider debate in the Church over the protection of minors. On November 12, the Pontifical University of the Holy Cross and the University of Notre Dame Law School held an international workshop in Rome. It marked the 25th anniversary of Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela, the 2001 motu proprio in which John Paul II set out the rules on the gravest offenses then reserved to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. These included the sexual abuse of a minor under 18 by a cleric.

About 200 people attended the event in the John Paul II Aula Magna. Speakers included the three men who have served as promoter of justice, the chief prosecutor, at the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith since 2002: Archbishop Charles J. Scicluna, Msgr. Robert W. Oliver and Jesuit Father Robert J. Geisinger. The organizers concluded that protecting minors is not a short-term response to legal requirements but a permanent, structural commitment that requires conversion of heart, prevention and defense of human dignity.

Based on reporting by Lucas Alonso for Iglesia Noticias. This article was translated and adapted from Spanish with the help of artificial intelligence.

More from Vatican