CHURCHGAZETTE

Saturday, November 21, 2026

World

82 percent of Catholics surveyed in Germany see deep divisions in their Church

A German study found most Catholic respondents see their Church split into traditionalist and reformist camps, with the role of women the most frequently cited source of division

People gathered inside a church
People gathered inside a church

A German study has found deep tensions between traditionalist and reform-minded Catholics, with the role of women the main point of disagreement.

The German association futur2 presented the results of its study "Polarization in the Church" (PiK-Studie) at an online session on November 11, 2026. The study was carried out by Ursula Hahmann and Valentin Dessoy. Fieldwork ran from May to July 2026 and covered 1,478 Catholics, 496 Protestants and more than 350 experts, including Catholic bishops, Protestant bishops and university professors. Of the Catholics surveyed, 82 percent said they see strong tensions in their Church, and nearly six in 10 now speak of two irreconcilable blocs.

Protestants reported less division. Among them, 56 percent see strong tensions, and only 28 percent describe opposing camps with no chance of reaching an understanding. Still, 62 percent of Catholics and 69 percent of Protestants believe constructive dialogue remains possible.

Role of women is the main dividing issue

The two churches are divided over different issues. Among Catholics, the role of women in the Church and in ordained ministry tops the list, named by 69 percent of respondents. Next come power, hierarchy and the understanding of ministry, cited by 41 percent. Protestants put debates over structures, resources and the future of their church first (51 percent), followed by the relationship between church and politics (44 percent).

When the study measured how emotionally charged each issue was, the treatment of same-sex couples proved the most contentious topic in both churches. Among Catholics, mandatory celibacy came a close second. Among Protestants, gender identity was second.

Irreconcilable blocs: traditionalists versus reformers

The authors point to a major structural difference. Protestants disagree issue by issue, while Catholics tend to split into a traditionalist bloc and a reformist bloc on almost every question. Hahmann and Dessoy said the central problem is not how far apart the positions are but how each side views the other. On every topic studied, respondents consistently rated people who hold different views from their own more negatively.

Hahmann said that among Catholics, 14 of the 15 issues examined carry so much emotional weight that a calm exchange is practically impossible. Traditionalist respondents gave reformers a score of 3.8 out of 7 for spiritual motivation, while reformers gave themselves 5.3. Disparagement also runs the other way, though less strongly. In the overall measure of feelings toward the other side, reformers view traditionalists more coldly.

Views of truth: objectivist or constructivist

The study also distinguishes between two ways of understanding truth. The objectivist view sees truth as something given and independent of the individual. The constructivist view ties it to experience and personal perspective. Of the participants, 66 percent fall into the constructivist category and only 13 percent into the objectivist one. Objectivists hold more conservative positions, perceive more polarization and judge it more harshly.

Women lean more toward constructivism than men. Among those under 35, however, the result was the opposite of what was expected: young Catholics are slightly more objectivist than older ones, and young men are the group closest to conservative positions. The gap between men and women is widest in that age group.

The core contradiction: stated ideals versus actual practice

Most respondents say they believe dialogue is possible, more than half support diversity within the Church, and nearly two-thirds accept views different from their own as a legitimate part of the Church. But the authors point to an underlying contradiction: the same people disparage the other side on almost every specific issue. Their stated ideals do not match their actual practice, the authors said.

Dessoy said each side attributes to the other a harshness it does not recognize in itself. He added that middle-ground positions are scarce in the Catholic Church, and that people who hold them can act as a bridge between the extremes precisely because they are less emotionally invested.

Proposals to reduce polarization

The authors propose shifting the debate from arguments to needs. Dessoy said the task is to negotiate "what both sides need, and not who is right." Hahmann said people should learn to separate the person from the position, and called for ground rules for coexistence even where there is no doctrinal consensus. "The Church is not a space sheltered from polarization," she said.

She also noted that the churches face difficult decisions about finances, property and structures, and that without mutual trust those decisions are very hard to make. During the presentation, several participants called for attention to the culture of debate. They urged conversation in the style of the worldwide Synod on synodality rather than the model of the German Synodal Way, the reform process led by the country's bishops and lay Catholics.

Methodological notes and next steps

The authors caution that the sample is not representative of Catholics as a whole. Half of the Catholics surveyed said they feel very closely tied to the Church, the same share attend Mass at least weekly, and 49 percent work for a Church institution. Data from the evangelical free churches was left out of the analysis because the sample was too small.

The results will be discussed December 2-3 in Bensberg, a town near Cologne, at futur2's ninth Strategy Congress, titled "Ignore, argue or... Fragmentation and polarization in the Church." The association has organized these meetings since 2008 and publishes an ecumenical online magazine under the same name.

Based on reporting by José García for Iglesia Noticias. This article was translated and adapted from Spanish with the help of artificial intelligence.

More from World