Vatican court reviews appeal by Spanish teacher convicted in Gaztelueta abuse case
The Apostolic Signatura must decide whether to overturn or uphold the canonical ruling that found José María Martínez, a teacher at Spain's Gaztelueta school, guilty of abusing a minor
Religión Confidencial, a Spanish Catholic news website, reported that the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura is reviewing an appeal by José María Martínez, a teacher at Gaztelueta, a school near Bilbao in northern Spain. Martínez is challenging the canonical ruling that convicted him of abusing a minor. Bishop José Antonio Satué signed the ruling when he was bishop of Teruel and Albarracín, in eastern Spain. He is now bishop of Málaga. The Signatura is headed by Cardinal Dominique Mamberti and is the Holy See's highest tribunal on administrative and procedural matters. The appeal is still under review, and the tribunal will have to rule on whether to overturn or uphold Satué's decision.
Martínez filed the appeal with his lawyer on April 29, 2025, a few weeks after he was notified of the ruling in March that year. On March 3, 2026, the Signatura said in writing that it had finished studying the appeal. Before going further, it required two steps: payment of the fees and the appointment of a rotal advocate, a lawyer specializing in canon law. Both were completed in the following weeks, and the case is now moving toward a final decision.
On his blog, Martínez described the Signatura as the "only body that can stop this absurdity." His last post is dated March 3, 2025, the day the ruling was published. The tribunal has changed since then. In July 2026, Pope Leo XIV, who trained as a canon lawyer, renewed part of its membership with five-year appointments. The appointees include Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco, Bishop Edward M. Lohse of Kalamazoo, Michigan, and Bishop Juan Ignacio Arrieta, along with canon lawyers Eduardo Baura, Krzysztof Nitkiewicz, Gianpaolo Montini and Ulrich Rhode.
Martínez's case has a long legal history. The acts he is accused of date from 2008 and 2010. An earlier canonical process ended with his acquittal in October 2015. In the Spanish courts, a lower court sentenced him to 11 years in prison. Spain's Supreme Court reduced the sentence to two years, finding insufficient evidence on the most serious charges. The court said there was "insufficient evidence and an assessment of it that we cannot endorse."
Pope Francis reopened the canonical case and assigned it to Satué in September 2022. In June 2022, Juan Cuatrecasas, a former student of Martínez, took part in "Amén, Francisco responde," a program in which Francis answered questions from young people. It aired in early 2023. Martínez tried without success to put his side of the story directly to Francis before he started writing a blog.
Martínez's defense and several experts have alleged serious irregularities in the way Satué handled the case. Rafael Palomino, a professor of law and religion, published a report saying that "the procedure was not a genuine criminal trial but an ad hoc disciplinary proceeding." He questioned "whether full papal authority can override fundamental legal principles and human rights." He concluded that the ruling "appears to be a response to outside pressure and media attention, rather than a process that adheres to due process guarantees." Benigno Blanco, a lawyer, has also publicly criticized the lack of procedural safeguards in the Church ruling. In 2023, the Signatura itself issued a decree signed by Mamberti rejecting an earlier appeal by Martínez's lawyers. That appeal challenged procedural points, including their request to remove Satué as judge.
Parallel civil case
Martínez also has a civil suit pending against Satué in a court in Pamplona, in northern Spain. He filed it in May 2024, alleging a violation of his right to honor, which under Spanish law protects a person's reputation. Martínez argued that the bishop's actions amounted to an "unlawful intrusion on my right to honor." The judge admitted the suit, with Satué named as defendant. The trial ended on May 5, 2026, and the court has not yet ruled.
Based on reporting by Lucas Alonso for Iglesia Noticias. This article was translated and adapted from Spanish with the help of artificial intelligence.